Meniscus tear treatment and arthroscopy

Meniscus tear

The meniscus tear is one of the most common knee injuries and usually occurs when the femur and tibia in the knee joint twist violently against each other under high pressure (knee torsion). This severely overloads the inner meniscus and can cause it to tear. Meniscus tears are common in younger people who do a lot of sports.

Symptoms
Causes
Diagnosis
Treatment
Aftercare
FAQs

Quick facts

  • Causes: the meniscus tear usually occurs when the femur and tibia in the knee joint twist violently against each other under high pressure (knee torsion)

  • Risks: sports with rapid changes of direction and frequent start-stop movements, previous conditions or a history of cruciate ligament surgery, old age, certain jobs

  • Symptoms: severe pain when twisting or bending, a popping or whipping noise, swelling in the knee

  • Treatment: Meniscus tears can be treated conservatively or surgically. The method of treatment depends on the age of the patient, the diagnosis and whether there are other knee injuries.

Symptome

A typical symptom of a meniscus tear is very severe pain when twisting or bending. Those affected often report a popping or whipping noise, along with swelling in the knee.

How a meniscus tear manifests also depends on the severity of the injury. If there is a major injury to the meniscus, movement of the knee is severely restricted and swelling of the knee occurs.

Less severe meniscal injuries often go unnoticed for some time. It can be the case that pain only arises after several hours or days. In some cases, it may be several weeks before the patient notices the meniscus damage.

Diagnosis

In order to confirm the meniscus tear, the doctor will carry out various examinations, as well as asking how the injury occurred.

  • During the initial examination, the doctor feels the knee to find out where the pain is or if there is swelling in any parts of the meniscus.
  • The knee is then bent and rotated in various positions. This creates pressure on different areas of the menisci, which triggers the pain.
  • An MRI is taken to rule out the possibility of injuries to other parts of the knee.

Causes

The meniscus can tear when the knee is twisted. The greatest risk of a meniscus tear occurs when the leg is twisted with the foot flat on the floor and the knee bent.

Risk factors

  • sports with rapid changes of direction and frequent start-stop movements, such as football, tennis and handball
  • Individuals with previous conditions or a history of cruciate ligament surgery also have an increased risk, as these affect the stability of the knee
  • Old age
  • Certain jobs that require frequent squatting or crouching

Treatments

Meniscus tears can be treated conservatively or surgically. The method of treatment depends on the age of the patient, the diagnosis and whether there are other knee injuries.

Conservative therapies

It is possible to live with a meniscus tear if you lead a less active lifestyle or if you can avoid all twisting and flexing of the knee joint in day-to-day life.

The main conservative treatment for a meniscus tear is physiotherapy. The aim of this is to strengthen the muscles and improve stability and mobility.

Surgical treatment

The meniscus will not grow back together by itself. There is a risk that the tear will get bigger with every turning movement, in which case the patient will experience new, stabbing pains in the knee. In the worst case scenario, the knee joint may become locked.

Surgery is usually recommended in the following cases:

  • when the affected individual is young and sporty
  • if conservative treatment has not provided an improvement in movement-induced pain
  • if mechanical complaints such as a locked knee or trapped nerve do not go away

There are different meniscus operations that can be carried out, such as:

  • meniscus suture
  • removal of the torn portion of the meniscus
  • meniscus replacement (in very rare cases)

The interventions are all minimally invasive with the help of joint endoscopy (arthroscopy). Small incisions of about one centimetre are made to the right and left of the kneecap tendon, through which a video camera and the appropriate instruments are inserted.

Meniscus suture

With the aid of meniscus suture, the torn meniscus tissue is connected to the healthy part of the meniscus and the joint capsule to reinstate the blood flow to the torn meniscus tissue, allowing the healing process to begin.

Not all meniscus tears can be sutured. The decision to go down the meniscus suture route depends on the age of the patient and the location of the tear. Whether or not a meniscus suture is possible can only be determined during the arthroscopy. In 20% of patients who have undergone this treatment, the suture does not heal and further tearing occurs. If this happens, the operation has to be repeated.

Removal of the torn meniscus

The most common procedure for a meniscus tear is removal of the meniscus. This is carried out when the meniscus has torn several times or has deteriorated so much over time that it can no longer be sutured. The part of the meniscus that is no longer functioning is removed, the aim being to remove “as little as possible, but as much as necessary.” This procedure is called a partial meniscus resection because only the torn pieces of the meniscus are removed. A meniscus resection is where the entire meniscus has to be removed. With these procedures, the problematic mechanical complaints are eliminated and the symptoms disappear very quickly.

However, this operation reduces the weight-bearing surface of the joint, which increases the risk of another tear if the knee is overloaded or twisted. It also increases the risk of osteoarthritis in the knee. Therefore, the first step is always the meniscus suture.

Meniscus replacement

In very rare cases, the meniscus needs to be replaced. Meniscus replacement is mostly used in younger patients with little or no cartilage damage. A meniscus transplant is performed using a donor meniscus. The replacement meniscus is made from polyurethane, which is gradually replaced by the body’s own tissue. It is also possible to fill the gap with biological tissue replacement.

Aftercare

Aftercare depends on the type of surgery.  During the aftercare period, physiotherapy is used to support movement and build muscle. This can take up to three months.

FAQs

Can a meniscus tear heal by itself?

Just like cartilage damage, a meniscus lesion does not regenerate on its own. For this reason, it makes sense to reconstruct the meniscus in young patients. This also applies to lesions in the area of the meniscus root.

Does a meniscus tear always require surgery?

Not all meniscus lesions require surgery. Lesions that are small, horizontal and do not pinch can be treated conservatively. The symptoms usually disappear after three to six months.

How long does meniscus surgery take?

The operation lasts between 30 and 60 minutes.

When can I go back to work after meniscus surgery?

Depending on the type of activity involved, the patient may be off work for up to eight weeks.

Doctors with this specialisation

Clinique Générale Ste-Anne

Dr. med. Daniel Monin

Specialisation
Orthopaedic surgery, Hip surgery, Knee pain and knee surgery, Osteoarthritis of the knee, Torn ligaments/ligament injuries, Meniscus tear, Cartilage damage, Knee prosthesis, Hip osteoarthritis, Hip prosthesis View more
View profile
Clinique Générale Ste-Anne

Dr. med. Stéphane Wachtl

Specialisation
Orthopaedic surgery, Shoulder surgery, Osteoarthritis of the shoulder joint, Calcific tendonitis of the shoulder, Frozen shoulder, Shoulder dislocation, Shoulder prosthesis, Rotator cuff rupture, Shoulder impingement, Knee pain and knee surgery, Knee arthroscopy, Osteoarthritis of the knee, Torn ligaments/ligament injuries, Meniscus tear, Cartilage damage, Knee prosthesis, Hip surgery, Hip osteoarthritis, Hip impingement, Hip prosthesis, ROSA® View more
View profile
Clinique Générale Ste-Anne

Dr. med. Behrang Allami

Specialisation
Orthopaedic surgery, Shoulder surgery, Osteoarthritis of the shoulder joint, Calcific tendonitis of the shoulder, Frozen shoulder, Shoulder dislocation, Shoulder prosthesis, Rotator cuff rupture, Shoulder impingement, Knee pain and knee surgery, Knee arthroscopy, Osteoarthritis of the knee, Torn ligaments/ligament injuries, Meniscus tear, Cartilage damage, Knee prosthesis, Hip surgery, Hip osteoarthritis, Hip impingement, Hip prosthesis View more
View profile
Clinique Générale Ste-Anne

Dr. med. Xavier De Raemy

Specialisation
Orthopaedic surgery, Knee pain and knee surgery, Knee arthroscopy, Osteoarthritis of the knee, Torn ligaments/ligament injuries, Meniscus tear, Cartilage damage, Knee prosthesis, Hip surgery, Hip osteoarthritis, Hip impingement, Hip prosthesis View more
View profile
Clinique Générale Ste-Anne

Dr. med. Peter Vyskocil

Specialisation
Orthopaedic surgery, Shoulder surgery, Osteoarthritis of the shoulder joint, Calcific tendonitis of the shoulder, Frozen shoulder, Shoulder dislocation, Shoulder prosthesis, Rotator cuff rupture, Shoulder impingement, Knee pain and knee surgery, Knee arthroscopy, Osteoarthritis of the knee, Torn ligaments/ligament injuries, Meniscus tear, Cartilage damage, Knee prosthesis, Hip surgery, Hip osteoarthritis, Hip impingement, Hip prosthesis, Foot/ankle surgery, Osteoarthritis of the ankle, Achilles tendon rupture, Heel pain, Hallux valgus, Morton’s neuroma View more
View profile
Clinique Générale Ste-Anne

Dr. med. Nicolas Vial

Specialisation
Orthopaedic surgery, Knee pain and knee surgery, Knee arthroscopy, Osteoarthritis of the knee, Torn ligaments/ligament injuries, Meniscus tear, Cartilage damage, Knee prosthesis, Hip surgery, Hip osteoarthritis, Hip impingement, Hip prosthesis, Foot/ankle surgery, Osteoarthritis of the ankle, Achilles tendon rupture, Heel pain, Hallux valgus, Morton’s neuroma View more
View profile

Find a doctor

Our specialists have many years of experience. We guarantee a quick, professionally competent clarification and consultation as well as treatment according to the most modern possibilities.
Call us
Write to us